Disturbing the Universe
I picked this up at a yard sale. Freeman Dyson is a physicist of the generation of Richard Feynman, and is perhaps best known for the concept of a Dyson Sphere (mentioned in this book), the idea that at a certain time in the development of a civilization they might attempt to enclose their star entirely so as to use as much of its energy as possible. In this book he writes of various aspect of his life and work, and some of his speculations for the future. Given that the book was published in 1979, it is of some interest to compare what he expected with the events of the past forty years, though I don’t know how deeply I’ll get into that here. Dyson is also clearly quite interested in poetry, which he seems to think gets to the heart of many matters, and it is incorporated liberally into the book.
Perhaps the thing that stuck me most was early in the book. Dyson, born and raised in England, though he would later become an American citizen, was part of the British bombing efforts during World War II, working to improve it operationally. For him even to reach this point was something of an evolution that he details, starting from rather a pacifistic world view and examining how it changed to allow him to reach the point where he was doing that job.
Interestingly, his conclusion is that the bombing campaign was pretty much a complete failure, that the results obtained were nowhere near justifying the costs incurred. The thing that interested me is perhaps illustrated in two different ways. First are examples he gives of improvements that he or his colleagues thought of and the reaction of the military staff and others to them.
One example had to do with the esacpe hatches in bombers. One of Dyson’s fellow workers did an analysis of these and their usage and concluded that they were simply too small to be used effectively in the kinds of situations where they would be needed. To get any action on this finding, however, required a protracted fight to get the commanders to recognize or admit that there was a problem, and then to get changes on new planes being manufactured. Not until near the end of the war was the change implemented, and many were lost who might otherwise have been spared.
An analysis by Dyson himself suggested that the gunners inside the bomber, put there to exchange fire with enemy fighters, actually had little effect on survival rates. Therefore, it would make sense to simply remove the gun turrets and gunners, reduce the crew, and spare the extra men when a plane was shot down. Naturally this challenged the conventional wisdom and was not received well. Dyson seems to have had less appetite for advocating for it than his friend, so nothing every happened. Nevertheless, it illustrates the difficulties with countering the conventional wisdom of institutions. One aspect of this difficulty is that the interests of individuals making up institutions is rarely completely aligned with the goals (even if not corrupted) of the institution as a whole, making it potentially risky for them personally to try changes that might improve the institution, even with the kind of substantiation that Dyson provided with his study. (And it should be noted here that while I do favor the idea of challenging conventional wisdom, it needs to be a challenge with evidence, not merely based on the fact that something is not as one wishes it to be.)
I think those ideas are pretty well known. What was interesting to me is it seems related to Dyson’s observation that the Bomber Command exemplified a method of waging war where no one actually felt responsible for killing anyone. In his words (p. 31):
Technology has made evil anonymous. Through science and technology, evil is organized bureaucratically so that no individual is responsible for what happens. Neither the boy in the Lancaster aiming his bombs at an ill-defined splodge on his radar screen, nor the operations officer shuffling papers at squadron headquarters, nor I sitting in my little office in the Operational Research Section and calulating probabilities, had any feeling of personal responsibility. None of us ever saw the people we killed. None of us particularly cared.
Dyson seems to find that troubling, and I certainly do. We can certainly say it is as bad or worse today in the military. How does a drone pilot feel, not even as physically present as the crew in a bomber? But even more disturbing is that this pervades our society. Among the other things that they are, corporations are vehicles to do exactly what Dyson describes - allow people to do objectionable things in such a way as they can feel (and in many legal senses, be) removed from the consequences that these actions create. This is not a problem that seems to admit an easy solution unless you are willing to either live with it or define the evil away (to me an entirely wrong-headed approach which, as anyone who reads my stuff for a while, will see that I think is commonly used by believers in a certain stream of economics). I spend a lot of time pondering it, though I have no expectation that I’ll be the one to crack it.
There are a lot of other interesting things in the book. Nuclear power, quite relevant at that time, is discussed quite a bit. Space exploration, space travel and speculation about other civilizations are prominent. There is some biology. The focus is rarely on the science or technology itself, but rather how it fits into society, with some element of both practical and philosophical viewpoint. Since this is an older book it is, as mentioned, interesting to see if society has been impacted as Dyson thought it would be, or if science has gone in the direction he believed it would. This is not primarily to see if he was right or not, but much more so to remind us to be humble about our own predictions of the future. Dyson is in some ways a contrarian, and I feel akin to him in that way. It’s always crucial to remember though, I think, that evidence is the root of everything - there is no value in going contrary to the evidence, but when the evidence is scant, then we should encourage the development of many viewpoints while we attempt to collect the evidence.