Grant
Memoirs and Selected Letters
I’m not all the way through this yet, but I’m going to go ahead and write anyway, as I doubt that further reading is going to change what I have to say all that much.
We know U.S. Grant primarily as a general during the Civil War and then later as president. His memoirs focus primarily on the campaigns he was in during the Civil War, though there is some material about his early life and the Mexican-American war. The campaigns are recalled in detail, often day by day, together with logistical, strategic, tactical, political, and even psychological considerations.
Grant impresses one as someone who is truly smart, not in that they try to convince you of that fact, but rather that they have the kind of humanity, humility, and honesty that you would expect to find of such a person.
Indeed, to me that most interesting parts of the book are not those that recount the particulars of military history, but rather the occasional tangent from that or step back to assess things from a broader perspective. Grant now and then drops some fine humor, such as the tale of his negotiating for a horse when he was young, or observing a “mutiny” on a ship. Often the humor is aimed at himself rather than others, as much great humor is.
He is also willing to give candid assessment of his own general and the enemies. Again, he is not spared here. He notes something that has always struck me, that there is some mythology risen around the Confederate generals that does not seem to extend to those of the Union, who seem to remain rather anonymous, which seems inexplicable since the Union won the war.
You can see some of the innovations that Grant made or incepted. It seems that some of the things attributed to Sherman have their genesis in Grant’s philosophy, though perhaps not taken as far there. The book seems to reinforce the old adage that good generals study strategy and great ones logistics. You also get a sense of his compassion for the soldiers, both in his and his enemies command.
It is also interesting to see how he conceived the United States in general, and how that relates to the differing views people have today. As an example I take some quotes from Chapter XVI, which also serve another purpose:
The framers were wise in their generation (my emphasis) and wanted to do the very best possible to secure their own liberty and independence, and that also of their descendants to the latest days. It is preposterous to suppose that the people of one generation can lay down the best and only rules of government for all who are to come after them, and under unforeseen contingencies.
(He then lists some changes since the times of the Founding Fathers.)
We could not and ought not to be rigidly bound by the rules laid down under circumstances so different for emergencies so utterly unanticipated. The fathers themselves would have been the first to declare that their prerogatives were not irrevocable.
Later in the chapter he talks about Southern elites demonizing Northerners and setting poor white vs. slave black as a means of maintaining their power, even though the interests of the latter two clearly coincide in the main, much more so than with the elites. Shades of Lyndon Johnson’s famous statement on the matter. Moreover, a government was only acceptable if it reinforced their views on the matter.
The fact is, the Southern slave-owners believed that, in some way, the ownership of slaves conferred a sort of patent of nobility - a right to govern independent of the interest or wishes of those who did not hold such property. They convinced themselves, first, of the divine origin of the institution and, next, that that particular institution was not safe in the hands of any body of legislators but themselves.
Shades of the economic elites of our day, no? I wanted to include some samples also to illustrate that the writing is clear and direct but also quite literary. In short, while I sometimes get a bit bogged down by the copious details of the military campaigns, the prose is a joy to read.
Grant is sometimes given short shrift, partially because of the corruption of his administration (though few believe he himself) as president and the aforementioned undeserved hagiography of those that Grant actually defeated in battle.
Now this is a memoir, though one reputedly checked well for facts, so that should always be taken into consideration. It is Grant’s own view of events, and though to me he seems to be honest in presenting things as objectively as he can, there is no question that there is room for subjectivity to creep in. Nevertheless I think this is well worth the lengthy read (it spans well over a thousand pages in the edition that I have) to get his viewpoint on the war and the continuing experiment that is the United States.