Sarah Smarsh grew up in rural Kansas, to the west of Wichita. This is the story of her and the family that she knew there, framed as a tale told to her never born daughter, the spectre of whose possibility always hung over her life.

The people in her family did things like farming, carpentry, waitressing, being a real estate agent, and so forth. And Smarsh did some of those as well on her way to becoming a professor of journalism. Women typically got married and had children young, not necessarily in that order - Smarsh early on decided that she didn’t want that to be her fate and worked against it, not wanting to see her daughter born into the same cycle of poverty that she was.

The point, though, is that this poverty is systemic rather than self-inflicted. Her family works hard, both men and women, but the institutions of society are constructed not to help but to hinder them from getting ahead. Moreover, the value system that is inculcated in them makes them believe that they, and not society as a whole, are responsible for their position. Smarsh regulary explores how various institutions and policies work against these people and for those already better off, and how they may nevertheless support those very policies. In some sense this book puts a very personal face on the issues in Thomas Frank’s “What’s the Matter with Kansas”. While I think the blame is fairly placed more heavily on certain areas of the political spectrum, no side is left unchallenged.

Though the family has many struggles - financial, physical, addiction, relationships and family - they also experience joys and happiness. They take pride in their work and do it as well as they can, even if they are not sufficiently rewarded for it.

As Smarsh remarks near the end, the daughter she has been speaking to will never be born - not necessarily because she won’t ever have a daughter, but because such a daughter would be born into radically different circumstances given the progression of her life, not to a young mother trapped in a cycle of poverty.

Smarsh reads the book herself. The delivery is somewhat flat, but I don’t say that as a negative. It conveys the character and characters of the book much better than an actor might have if they decided to do it in a more dramatic fashion. The people in the book are not simple or straightforward in who they areq, but their manners are fairly plain and down to earth.