I read this book a while ago and the details aren’t fresh, so I’m not going to put down too much here, since the ideas here interact with other sources and I don’t want to conflate too much. That shouldn’t be taken as a negative against the book - it’s really good.

It’s a common assertion among the religious that morality and ethics must naturally flow from a god or other religious source. Zuckerman’s book is not only a rebuttal of this claim and a demonstration of how perfectly natural factors may logically produce ethics, but takes a stronger stance that morals necessarily cannot be produced from a god.

The basic philsophical argument on the second point is that if on the one hand morality is simply a question of obedience to God then it is fairly meaningless as God can equally well order us to love our neighbor as ourselves as to commit genocide - and indeed the Bible contains both (but this is more a historical than philosophical point). Moreover these are completely arbitrary commands. On the other hand, if God can only ask us to be moral in a way that conforms to some outside notion of morality, then God is unnecessary in the equation. Of course, Zuckerman states it better than this. He asserts that theists have no real response to it; I’d be interested to know what the attempts are.

So what then of secular morality? On a practical level, more secular societies (here the canonical examples are places like the Nordic countries) seem to produce greater happiness and well-being for their citizens, less crime, and so forth. Secular people don’t seem to descend into some sort of feral, dog-eat-dog state defined by self-interest and selfishness. And so on. You can measure a lot of this stuff via various social sciences and when you do you just don’t see problems.

On a more theoretical level, then, where does it come from? Why don’t people descend into a mire or selfishness? The short answer is that humans have evolved as social animals. Cooperation was (and continues to be) fundamental to their existence. Therefore it’s no grand surprise that they develop systems to enable this cooperation. Now that is clearly a giant oversimplification, but it’s at the root of things. I have another review for a book called Moral Tribes that goes into this sort of thing more, including the important in/out group distinction, why that might have evolved, and what issues it causes in the modern world.