I just wanted to make some more observations about the ideas of Moral Tribes.

An example that Greene uses to illustrate his views on rights is that of healthcare. A casual mention of healthcare in a mixed crowd is apt to bring on cries that it is a human right and opposing cries that is is not and that it conflicts with other rights. However, the sides seem to get closer together if the discussion is directed away from rights into the factual details of how various healthcare systems work, and what their particular advantages, disadvantages, and costs are. This corresponds with activating manual mode over automatic mode in our thinking. And this is the type of things Greene is looking for.

The other point I wanted to look at was my pessimism that this will actually work in practice, no matter how I might wish that it would. I wonder how getting people to agree even on measuring happiness would work. For example in America you can find those who will swear up and down that gay people must be profoundly unhappy for some reason that derives not from societal biases and taboos against them but from some innate factor of their humanity, and if those societal factors were removed they would still not be happy. Such a segment of the population is unlikely to agree on how to increase the happiness of these people, and is even unlikely to agree that they are happy even if they claim to be so. I think we can find this sort of disconnect more broadly. It’s unclear to me how it can be overcome.