The Economy
Well, in these days we’re hearing a lot of talk about the balance between containing coronavirus and the effects on the economy. Perhaps the best quote that I’ve read was something to the effect of - if we need millions of people to die for the economy to work, then the economy is not working.
This is basically a drum that I’ve been beating for some time in a broader context. That is, you hear things like - we can’t tackle this or that environmental issue (be it small or climate change) because it would be bad for the economy. We can’t pay a living wage, because it would be bad for the economy. We can’t assure people have healthcare or give everyone the tools they need to have a happy and fulfilling life, because… you guessed it.
At what point do you admit that perhaps the economy is not something to be served and protected, but is itself the problem? When do you admit that an economy is just a tool that can be used or discarded in favor of another economy (again a tool) to achieve the actual things that society wants. To be clear, in my view the economy is not a primary concern. It is only something that you use to achieve your real goals.
However, it’s obviously a very complex and unpredictable thing. So it is to be expected that it will require constant maintaining. You have to constantly evaluate how well it is helping you fulfill your goals. When and where it is not, it must be adjusted. It may have side effects that were not (and maybe could not) be foreseen. So it may require adjustment or replacement for that reason.
I think that any reasonable evaluation of capitalism has to face this. I may rag on it, but clearly it did a good job of replacing what came before it and did in fact make life better for more people. That doesn’t mean that it can work forever, just that it helped in a certain context. Now more than ever it’s obvious what problems it doesn’t solve and what it actually creates. So a reasonable society would take stock of that and modify or replace to handle those things. There isn’t actually any reason, I think, to believe that there is a particular “ideal” economic system that can be reached, rather one needs to look at the current context and see what needs to happen there. But people seem loath to embrace this idea.
And to veer a little bit, once when I was in graduate school I was sitting at my desk and I wrote down a proof that every function is analytic. Now, this is somewhat absurd, as not every function is in fact analytic. In fact almost none of them are by any reasonable measure. My reaction was not to double down on the analyticity of all functions. Instead, I thought to myself, well, that can’t be right, and set about finding where the error in my “proof” was. I wonder how it is that some people can say things like seniors should be willing to sacrifice their lives for the economy without stopping, saying to themselves, no that doesn’t sound quite right, and retracing their reasoning to see where the error is. Well, I suspect that there isn’t any reasoning, just hewing to ideology. So maybe I do know.