As sometimes happens I got a bit of a surprise with this book. Having selected it from Libby with only a glance at the title, not even the subtitle, I expected something perhaps more rhetorical in nature. That is, perhaps strategies for actually arguing with a racist in a rhetorical sense, strategies for argumentation without provoking digging in, etc.

That’s not what I got. The book is really about why race as a biological construct is nonsense. As you might expect, this is also of interest to me. Rutherford is an researcher into genetics from England and of Indian descent. The book is primarily about laying out the factual information from genetics that makes the idea that race is genetic in nature absurd.

Given that we do have race as a concept in society, it seems to follow then that it is a socially constructed thing and that when someone ascribes certain properties to certain races it must therefore come from a cultural context.

An example, which I hope I’m remembering well enough given that I read (or listened) to this some time ago is in the area of sports. Rutherford naturally accepts that individual genetic variation has a lot to do with success in sports. There is no question that I was never destinted to be a great basketball player, for example. However, this simply does not transfer to race, and differences seen here come about in his view, a quite convincing one, for cultural reasons.

For example the reason that a lot of world class long distance runners come from certain parts of Africa is that those regions have cultural factors that cause that. Their past and current success inspire people in those areas to take up and value that sport. The training expertise and facilities are good there and geared to that sport. And so on.

I found the book interesting. I don’t know, for the purposes of American racism, how useful I think it is. That is, I’m not sure that knowing this stuff is going to enable you to change minds. I’m not sure that majority of racists are going to accept the facts or even if they do follow them to the logical conclusions. Still, maybe some would, and the genetics is interesting enough on its own merits.