I suppose that any discussion of Mondern Monetary Theory (MMT) is likely to be controversial. It definitely is a relatively new approach to macroeconomics and is not the orthodox view. Kelton is an economist that works in MMT. I am not an economist, so please take my comments with a grain of salt and do some reading like this for a better view. Moreover it has been a bit since I listend to the book, so my view may be foggy.

MMT is basically relevant to entities that issue their own currency. That is, it applies to a country like the United States, but it does not apply to states in the US, nor to countries in the Eurozone that use the Euro and cannot issue it.

The key observation is that such entities cannot run out of money. They are in control of issuing the money and can issue as much as they like. Thus, deficits and the idea of not having enough money to do things are wholly an artificial creation. They simply don’t matter. The fact that so many people buy into the idea (whether by ignorance or because having that idea be believe is useful to their priorities) that they do matter prevents a realistic evaluation of what can be done.

Kelton is quick to point out that this doesn’t mean that deficits should be run or that there are no limitations. The point is more that there should be discussion about what the society wants to achieve and what the real limitations are, like worker availability, natural resources, and inflation, and that fiscal and monetary policy should be directed to maximizing societal gain while respecting those limitations rather than the artifical one of having an arbitrary deficit policy.

I had understood some of these ideas (and will admit I am sympathetic to them) before reading the book. One of the main questions that it answered for me is - then why do people value this sort of money? The answer that I had been familiar with is that it’s just kind of a trust in the system, that there is just kind of general societal agreement that we’re going to use it and have confidence in it. The MMT answer that Kelton gives is not quite so loose - the currency has value because the issuer has the ability to demand payment in the currency. That is, the government has the right to demand that you pay taxes in its currency and can penalize you if you don’t. That actually gives the currency tangible value.

So what would be the value of running the economy the way MMT suggests? An example would be removing involuntary unemployment. The government could establish a program where anyone who wanted a job would have one at some set base rate of pay. Money does not need to be found to do this - we decide the policy goal, establish if the real resources (in this case people and natural resources to do the jobs that would be created) exist, and then just do it.

Am I an economist? No, as stated earlier. Do I find this kind of reasoning compelling? Fairly well so. Are there detractors? Absolutely, and you can find their stuff and read it as well. Does Kelton provide evidence that these ideas can work and that they can avoid problems that other economic theories cause? I think so, but again, I’m not the best to evaluate here.

I will reemphasize something that I’ve said elsewhere before. Those who would have you believe that there is some canonical, natural economic system are clearly full of it. You just don’t get to avoid responsibility for the economic system that you implement and pains that it causes to real humans by claiming that there is. That is maybe a meta-fact that needs to be fought for in the minds of people in order to avoid laziness in this and to have real discussions about how different economic systems will work and what they will achieve. I don’t expect that people will then agree on what to do, but at least we’ll be honest about how the economic policies that we implement will affect people and that we could have done otherwise, with different effects. And the discussion can lie where it should - on what we as a society want to achieve and how to mediate these goals between different people and groups, and then only once that is achieved figure out how to organize an economy to get there.