This is a breezy read, apparently based on a podcast of the same name. It was in the new books section at the library and looked interesting, so I thought I’d pick it up. Skepticism is the main them of the book. Steven Novella is a medical doctor, so it should be no surprise that neurological factors are well covered and that examples related to medicine are prominent.

To me the most valuable part was the first half, dealing largely with things like proper and improper argument, elements of human psychology relevant to how we think about things, etc., entitled “Core Concepts Every Skeptic Should Know”. I don’t want to go into a lot of details, as it would be hard to cover everything, but some examples should help give the flavor of what is going on.

They start by going over the many ways in which things like memory and perception are, biologically, suspect. Our memories change as time passes, and it is surprisingly easy for them to alter to accord with others, or even for false memories to be produced. Our perceptions at the present are to a large extent infuenced by our brain, which fills in things that our physical body is unable to sense using its own model of the world. We tend to miss things. (E.g. the famous ‘gorilla experiment’ where subjects watch a video with the mission of counting something like the number of passes of a ball people make. During the course of the video, someone in a gorilla costume comes into the picture and walks around. Something like half the test subjects do not notice it.)

This then bleeds over into more psychological effects. Dunning-Kruger is a ready example here, that is the tendency of people who know little about a subject to vastly overestimate how much they know about it - although Novella points out that event experts tend to overestimate their knowledge, though the amount is smaller. Various types of psychological biases are covered.

Logical fallacies are also covered. Unlike the preceding, which are endemic to us as humans, though we can recognize and try to limit their effects, logical fallacies can be carefully reasoned about - and they can also be used intentionally to deceive (though it is not always the case that someone employing them is doing so). The usual suspects are found here, such as:

  • Argument by Ignorance - we can’t prove something isn’t true, so it is true
  • Appeal to Authority - someone is a position of authority says something, so it is true, whether or not there is evidence for it
  • False Dichotomy - you don’t know the answer, hence my answer must be right (even though there is no evidence for it either, and excluding the very real possibility of other answers)
  • Slippery Slope - a slippery slope will be slipped, even though it is entirely possible that, well, it won’t be
  • Strawman - misrepresenting one’s opponent’s arguments and evidence in order to have an easier target to argue against

I can’t go through them all, but merely reading and understanding chapter 10 would be a tremendous improvement to the reasoning ability of most people. Novella is careul not to remind us to not let ourselves off the hook - everything he talks about applies equally well to ourselves, and if we are truly in pursuit of truth rather than some other end, we need to consciously bring all of this type of knowledge to bear when we think and constantly check that we ourselves are not falling into traps in our own thinking. We should also be generous when considering how others think and know that much here happens automatically and biologically. We ought to help others understand these things, but be gentle about it.

If the above sounds interesting, then the other parts of the first section are likely to be interesting as well, though I’ll not go into them in detail. The last that I’d like to mention is discussion of chance and coincidence. Given my background in mathematics it is not surprising that this connects with me. I like to state the main thrust of it something like this: any given coincidence is unlikely, however, there are so many possible coincidences, and our brains are such good machines at looking for them, that not seeing any, or indeed a lot of them, is itself extremely unlikely.

The relevance here is that we tend to see coincidences and other unlikely occurences and ascribe (possibly causal) meaning to them that they do not deserve. The simple fact of the matter is that equally well something other rare event could have happened and we would then have tried to ascribe meaning to it. Done properly, one thing that science is good at is figuring out when there is a real effect and when we just happen to be seeing a meaningless coincidence. And indeed, seeing a rare event can trigger a search for a real effect - but the observation and initial interpretation of the event is not the place to stop, but the place to start. Most of the time, it will actually mean nothing.

Once we have some of the basic biological, psychological, and logical ideas in mind we can then proceed to hit the real world with them. The rest of the book is devoted to that. Some highlights include treatments of cold reading, intelligent design, paranormal phenomena, good and bad general and science reporting, and pseudoscience/pseudomedicine. One could fairly easily dip into any of these at will and have an interesting little read.

Whether or not they use this book, I can’t recommend highly enough that people learn the kinds of things it covers about how humans actually think and about logical fallacies that interfere with good thinking and apply them to the world. I can only imagine that that would make things better.

On a personal note it is worth briefly addressing how I advocate this sort of thing and remain a theist. I don’t go looking for supernatural explanations for things that admit perfectly good natural ones. I think that the plain evidence of the universe as it exists is not only true, but is in fact necessary for us to have in order to apply theistic principles. To wit, the better you understand the universe the better you are able to apply that knowledge to interact morally with its other inhabitants. Conversely, if you choose to ignore what is known and knowable about the universe, willfully or not, then you diminish your ability to live morally.

As a consequence, I am probably removing any ability to apply evidenciary procedure to matters of faith, and I’m okay with that. One might object then that I am falling into a god of the gaps position, and such a criticism is not entirely unfair, although I do think it is possible to maintain that there is a real division that is fundamental and not driven merely by our state of knowledge without being able to say exactly where it is. (As a mathematical analogy, it may be possible to prove that a set of numbers has an upper bound without having any idea what that upper bound may be.) As always, it is possible that I’m wrong, but here I am.