What Money Can't Buy
the Moral Limits of Markets
The basic thrust of this book is suggested in the title. Pure economic factors don’t seem to produce a society that meets the criteria that we think of as defining morality. Sandel examines this. I’d like to discuss my viewpoint on the general question first, then go into some things that Sandel brings up that I found interesting, perhaps with some illustrative examples.
Implicit in the desire to have this discussion is the idea that morals are independly definable from market economics. I think this obvious, but there is a school of economics that would deny that this is the case, but rather that market outcomes defined in a certain way actually define morality. I find this absurd, but you can find people who believe it. To me this is symptomatic of a desire to define an axiomatic system and derive consequences from it without ever referencing the actual world, then to complain about how the world is when it looks different than the theory’s predictions. A physical analogy would be for me to decide that I’m going to take Newton’s mechanics as a definitive description of the world. Then when we observe things about the universe that don’t fit these laws, instead of inventing relatvity and quantum mechanics we rage against the universe and complain that it should act more like Newton’s theory says.
If from the above you glean that I am of the opinion that economics, as much as physics, needs to be empirical and to constantly match up real world observations with theory and that theory is what needs to give way when mismatches are found, then you are correct. And if you agree then this book might be of interest to get at a little bit how markets themselves are not sufficient to provide what we commonly think of as moral.
Two ideas in the book particularly connected with me, those of fairness and corruption. Sandel contends that these are not well handled by market models. So what do we make of them?
Corruption, in Sandel’s sense, is not (necessarily) what we commonly think of. It has a more technical meaning, which I take roughly as what happens when putting a previously non-market good into a market fundamentally changes it. Classical economic theory has no way to account for this, and some might even deny that it happens. Sandel, and I, think that it can. An example of what he is talking about , found here and in other sources, comes from the world of daycare.
A daycare would occasionally have parents come late to pick up their children. Of course, this is an inconvenience for the daycare workers. To attempt to reduce this, the daycare instituted a charge to parents when they were late to pickup. The result of this was that late pickups became more common. As Sandel points out, this was the opposite of what one would expect from a purely economic perspective. Surely you should be less likely to be late if it costs you some money to do so.
The resolution of this dilemma according to Sandel is corruption, i.e. the good changed in some way when market forces were introduced. Without payment we had a social contract. People would be late only if it were truly unavoidable, out of courtesy or the desire not to be jerkish. Formalizing the system to include payment allowed them to look at it as a contractual and acceptable action. They felt like they would no longer need to feel guilt about the action.
Fairness, as I took it, has to do with the discrepancy between willingness to take an economic action and ability to take that action. A good example here is from the world of sports, where you may see the most rabid of fans in the cheap, undesirable seats while much more casual fans are sitting in the prime sections. (No one is suggesting that it is universal, but it commonly happens.) If their economic situations were equal, it is likely that the hard core fans would be willing to pay more for the good seats, but if they are less well off, they lack the ability if not the desire to do so.
This naturally leads into all kinds of philosophical questions about how to construct a just and moral society. I don’t want to pursue all of that here. The relevant part to me is that the market based schemes don’t seem to produce a result that is consistent with intuitive ideas of what is fair in this situation, and as I’ve observed, merely stating that this is what markets produce hence it is the optimal outcome rings hollow to me, like we have no ability to make moral judgements outside of the purview of markets and economics.
These examples are enough to give the general sense of the book. There are many more, involving such diverse areas as insurance, medical care, environmental concern, and advertising. Commonly economic and more philosophical analyses are contrasted. For the audience of this book, the economic analysis will typically have something missing that we can recover or at least sense when expanding our viewpoint beyond pure economics.
Lest one think that I have no regard for economics, let me state that this is not true. However, I feel that it is at its best when it is firstly being done as an empirical science, as I suggested earlier, and not just mathematics. And secondly if it is taken as a tool to try to solve issues suggested in other ways (e.g. our moral sense) rather than as a definer of that sense. I think it can work in that way, although our attempts to use it must always themselves remain the subject of observation and judgement, as the daycare example shows.
I think that this book is a good introduction to these issues and a good compendium of examples to consider when thinking about them. At some point I did feel like the same points were being made over and over with only minor changes, but that is not a big criticism, and the ideas would come across as well if a reader were simply to skip over some of the examples.