Disturbing the Universe

by Freeman Dyson

I picked this up at a yard sale. Freeman Dyson is a physicist of the generation of Richard Feynman, and is perhaps best known for the concept of a Dyson Sphere (mentioned in this book), the idea that at a certain time in the development of a civilization they might attempt to enclose their star entirely so as to use as much of its energy as possible. In this book he writes of various aspect of his life and work, and some of his speculations for the future. Given that the book was published in 1979, it is of some interest to compare what he expected with the events of the past forty years, though I don’t know how deeply I’ll get into that here. Dyson is also clearly quite interested in poetry, which he seems to think gets to the heart of many matters, and it is incorporated liberally into the book.

Free Range Kids

by Lenore Skenazy

A fun book about a movement to which I am sympathetic. The idea is that we overworry about a lot of things with respect to children nowdays in spite of the fact that statistically we should not, and that perhaps it would be better for the children if we did not. Crime rates have been dropping for around 25 years, and the benefits of allowing children some extra freedom and ability to do things and explore on their own without having parents hovering about (benefits accruing to both the children and parents, no less) far exceed the small potential of harm that comes of doing that.

The Skeptics Guide to the Universe

How to Know What's Really Real in a World Increasingly Full of Fake

by Steven Novella, Bob Novella, Cara Santa Maria, Jay Novella, and Evan Bernstein

This is a breezy read, apparently based on a podcast of the same name. It was in the new books section at the library and looked interesting, so I thought I’d pick it up. Skepticism is the main them of the book. Steven Novella is a medical doctor, so it should be no surprise that neurological factors are well covered and that examples related to medicine are prominent.

To me the most valuable part was the first half, dealing largely with things like proper and improper argument, elements of human psychology relevant to how we think about things, etc., entitled “Core Concepts Every Skeptic Should Know”. I don’t want to go into a lot of details, as it would be hard to cover everything, but some examples should help give the flavor of what is going on.

What Money Can't Buy

the Moral Limits of Markets

by Michael J. Sandel

The basic thrust of this book is suggested in the title. Pure economic factors don’t seem to produce a society that meets the criteria that we think of as defining morality. Sandel examines this. I’d like to discuss my viewpoint on the general question first, then go into some things that Sandel brings up that I found interesting, perhaps with some illustrative examples.

Implicit in the desire to have this discussion is the idea that morals are independly definable from market economics. I think this obvious, but there is a school of economics that would deny that this is the case, but rather that market outcomes defined in a certain way actually define morality. I find this absurd, but you can find people who believe it. To me this is symptomatic of a desire to define an axiomatic system and derive consequences from it without ever referencing the actual world, then to complain about how the world is when it looks different than the theory’s predictions. A physical analogy would be for me to decide that I’m going to take Newton’s mechanics as a definitive description of the world. Then when we observe things about the universe that don’t fit these laws, instead of inventing relatvity and quantum mechanics we rage against the universe and complain that it should act more like Newton’s theory says.

The Prodigal Tongue

The Love-Hate Relationship Between American and British English

by Lynne Murphy

This is a delightful little book whose focus is pretty well conveyed by its title. One might consider the central organizing principle to be the British Verbal Superiority Complex versus the American Verbal Inferiority Complex, but it is much more than just that.

The book, written by an American linguistics professor who is a long time expatriate in England, goes well beyond the shallow differences that we often think of when comparing these two “nationlects” as she likes to call them, such as the extra ‘u’s that seem to pop up in British words (from my American perspective) or talking of lifts instead of elevators. It’s a fun romp through linguistic differences and exploration of how the two nationlects influence each other. It’s even a fun exploration of when they haven’t influenced each other, even though one side or the other thinks they have. (For example, the English are likely to blame anything they don’t like about their language on America, even if it came from say Australia, New Zealand, or even England. Or, Americans are likely to think that anything sufficiently funny sounding came from England, like the word ‘bumbershoot’. Murphy reveals that Brits have no idea what that is - in fact it came from an American film about English people, Chitty-Chitty Bang-Bang.)

Introduction

I’ve decided to change from using Zim to hugo, so this is a start to that end. I’ll move the existing content over in some form, or maybe I won’t. Who knows?

Someone else and everyone

Not too long ago Paul Allen, the co-founder of Microsoft, died. In remembrance Bill Gates said something to the effect that personal computing would not have come about without the efforts of Allen.

While I don’t wish to minimize Gates’s tribute to his friend, this is absurd and the fact that we see this kind of thinking is detrimental to society. If Paul Allen had not been in that position, we cannot say exactly how personal computing would have come about. What we can say with perfect surety is that it simply would have been someone else. The ingredients were there, and someone would have done it. Einstein is justly famous for his physical theories, but if he hadn’t come up with relativity, it just would have been someone else. The magic is not in these individuals, but in having the type of society that is able to produce them, or in their absence, someone else who can do the same thing. To think to the contrary, that there is something incredibly unique in them that their absence would deny to the worlk is, I think, destructive. It focuses our attention on them instead of the problems of maintaining and improving the society that is able to produce them, and it diminishes the role of everyone.

Fundraisers and such

First with my nephews and now with my daughter there seem to be periodic school fundraisers. Let us forego for the moment the absurdity of the fact that schools need to do this sort of thing in order to obtain funding that they require. The fundraisers generally are of the nature of buying some sort of product from a company that may specialize in doing this sort of thing, or perhaps not. Regardless, a potion of the profit then goes to the school. I have some experience with this sort of thing myself, as my marching band or chess fundraisers in high school were sometimes of a similar nature, most notably selling subscriptions to magazines.